From the Coin Commentary Archive

March 31, 2011: First Quarter Colonial Auction Recap


The following article by our own John Agre appeared in the Colonial Coin Collector's Club (C4) Newsletter, but since not all of our website visitors are C4 members, we thought we'd go ahead and post it here for your reading pleasure (though with the addition of a bunch of no-holds-barred editorial comments that we reserved for this site):

It’s been a pretty interesting first three months of the year in the world of colonial coin auctions, with significant offerings from Stack’s and Heritage, an interesting piece or two at Bowers and Merena, and an assortment of coins on Ebay ranging from the fairly typical (i.e. a ton of Chinese copies), to the pretty nice (lots of contemporary counterfeits and an occasional attractive type coin) to the (almost) once-in-a-lifetime-coin-you-never-expected-to-see-anywhere, let alone on Ebay.

Fortunately, your author attended all of the live sessions in person, bidding, watching, taking copious notes, kibitzing and availing himself of the free food (which in many cases was delicious) and can now spew forth with observations.

So let’s begin at the beginning, with the Heritage FUN auctions on January 3rd with the “Signature” session (for coins valued at roughly $1,500 to $10,000). And it was a decent auction, which brought prices that were frankly all over the map:

Lot #3004, a lovely, original, evenly struck Pine Tree Small Planchet Shilling of the common Noe-29 variety in an NGC Fine 12 holder brought a strong $3,450 for the grade.  But that was a far better than average example, and the demand for Mass silver that looks like that is as high as ever (it is worth noting that examples that are not nice, that have been cleaned, or are impaired in some way even if they are in holders, is low, and such pieces can regularly found on Ebay and elsewhere gathering numismatic dust).

Lot #3006, a nice looking Newman 6-F American Plantation Token in an AU58 PCGS holder brought a healthy $4,312.50, the latest (at that time) in a series of strong performances by American Plantation die varieties at auctions.  So if you own a rare variety of Plantation Token, I would consign it to auction if I were you.

Lot #3017, a 1670-A French Colonies 5 Sols in an MS62 PCGS holder brought a staggering (to me) $19,550.  I say staggering because that same coin brought exactly half that amount ($9,775) when it last sold at Heritage just two short years ago in May of 2008.  I can only conclude that this was purchased by a die variety specialist, or someone who saw an otherwise hidden value in this piece that I didn't.

But while that piece appreciated nicely, not everything in the next evening’s Platinum Night session (earmarked for coins valued at roughly $10,000 and up) followed the same trajectory:

Lot #5402, a New Yorke Token graded F15 by PCGS sold for “just” $18,400, well less than the $32,200 this same piece brought at that same Heritage auction in May of 2008.  Ouch.

Lot #5403, a 1787 New York Excelsior Copper enthusiastically graded AU55 by PCGS (despite a square dig in the central reverse) sold for $34,500.  Interestingly, this piece too can be traced to that same May 2008 Heritage sale, but this one went up since that time, having sold for $29,900 2.5 years ago.  Personally, it pains your author that this impaired specimen has been the pop 1/0 finest graded specimen at PCGS for years, while the two below it at AU53 on the pop report are clearly finer in every respect and have sold for signficantly higher prices privately in recent years to eager buyers (we know, becuase we sold both of them).  Heck, we'd take most of the AU50's and XF45's we've seen over this AU55, too.

Lot #5407, the New York Theatre Token graded PF64 by PCGS, went the other way, selling for $32,200 compared to the $40,250 it brought in 2008, but exactly the same as the $32,200 this frequently traded item brought a year earlier at Heritage in August 2007.

But that wasn’t as exciting as lot # 5408, the Washington Roman Head Cent in a PF61 PCGS holder.  By my count this is the 5th different example of this type to come to market since May 2004.  And many readers will remember this coin when it was first offered in a November 2005 Smythe sale, described extreeeeeemly optimistically as “Gem Proof”, offered uncertified, where it brought (if memory serves) in the low $40K’s (signaling the first run-up of this type from its historical level).  Then it came to Heritage in 2008 and brought a very, very robust $92,000.  Which brings us to the present session, where it brought “only” $66,125 (a 28% decline in 2.5 years).  I guess one can at least say that this was a better deal for the buyer than the guy who won it in 2008.

I don’t know what to conclude about this session in general other than to say that a number of these coins seem to have traded quite frequently in recent years, with a great deal of volatility.

The next session of note would be held by Bowers and Merena, also in Tampa, containing just 15 colonials, but with one notable piece:

Lot #59, a Sommer Islands Twopence graded AG3 by PCGS, realized $18,400, which I guess represents the most affordable version of one of these coins in a PCGS holder (a mandatory requirement for a lot of monied buyers these days).

The next auction of note would be a few weeks later at Stack’s with their Americana session, and though it was held in a blizzard (as was well documented in our Road Report from that auction) most of the usual suspects were in attendance, either in person, or via representative, including at least one well known colonial dealer who made it with literally seconds to spare before his first target lot came up.

The first really interesting lot was the first colonial, lot #5801, a genuinely attractive Willow Tree Shilling that was, according to the catalog, found by a metal detectorist in a Massachusetts farm field (which sounds suspiciously like my yard), brought $43,125 to a book bid and was sold seemingly before anyone could blink.  I looked at that coin under a loupe for about 10 minutes and honestly thought it was better than some Oaks and Pines I've seen in straight graded holders (though, of course, I am not a professional coin grader).

Lot #5805, an American Plantation Token 4-D variety described as a die combination “whose existence is not confirmed” in the Whitman Encyclopedia of Colonial & Early American Coins (which I found confusing, since this particular example has been known and was described accurately, as noted in the current catalog, in another auction 38 years ago) brought $25,300 (a new public auction record for any coin in this series).  As an aside, I met the consignor of this coin a few weeks after the sale and he was very, very surprised with this result, since he had been told in the past that it was a "restrike" with limited value.

Lot 5836, a rare Virginia Penny in what might be the most affordable condition possible (cleaned, with some surface business) brought a very strong $17,250 on the floor.  That was not too far below the price of some pretty choice examples in recent years.

Lot 5838, the newly discovered and very crusty (i.e. totally original and unconserved) Pitt Farthing with full, brilliant silvering(!) graded AU55 by PCGS and the best one I have ever personally seen (though there is a known specimen plated in an old reference book considered to be a full blown unc. which was curiously not mentioned by the current cataloger) brought what I thought was a fair $94,875 to the bidder noted above who showed up just in time to buy it.

And then the state coppers started, featuring a lot of collector grade coins with minor and not-so-minor problems, including a long list of NJ coppers in low grade that realized roughly $100 to $300 (with the low point being lot #5936 at $23 (twenty-three) all-in.  I do not know what the consignor had paid for all these coins back in the day, but I assume they were bargains.  I could not help but thinking, though, that if he had spent just a little more, and acquired pieces with better color and surfaces, they would have sold for many (possibly many-many) multiples of those prices in this session.

However, a handful of his rarities did plenty well enough to carry the day, and, in total, I am sure this set proved to be a very good investment through the years.

Lot #5956, a Maris 37-X NJ, considered to be Rarity-7, and frankly a pretty decent looking F/VF which I believe the consignor cherry-picked years ago, brought $17,250.

Lot #6016, a Maris 83-ii variety, also R-7 and described as the “7th finest of 9 known” (though with a look only a mother could love) brought $18,400 to another specialist.

Which led us to the Machin’s Mills coinage, where lot #6051, a newly discovered unique variety in well worn but not-unattractive condition brought a very strong $40,250 to another specialist.

The next notable auction would not be held by a big company, in a large room, and there would be no buffet served.  This one would be on Ebay, where a formerly unique New Jersey Maris 18-L suddenly appeared on January 30th, completely out of the woodwork, previously unknown, but (and here’s the kicker) correctly attributed on a 35+ year-old ANACS grading certificate, and housed in a PCGS VF35 holder.  Also, and just as surprisingly, it looked attractive (which, in my experience, is not the norm for rare things that just sort of pop up).  And, as has been reported extensively in the trade press and numismatic chatrooms, it did very, very well, running from its $995 starting bid up to $50K+ over the next week, jumping to $71K in the late stages and then, finally, to the nice round winning number of $105,655.55 in the final seconds.

My view is that that’s probably about what it would have brought in any venue (or at least any venue where the major players knew about it – which was definitely the case here).

This was a significant enough event that it found its way to the cover of Coin World, which is infrequent territory for things colonial.

And then we were back to catalogs, and podiums and auctioneers and stuff, this time at the Heritage Long Beach auction which had some more notable pieces in it:

Lot #3001, a Noe-7 Oak Tree Shilling in a VF30 PCGS holder, brought $7,475, which is a fair bit more than the $5,577.50 this same coin brought when sold raw at Stack’s in March of 2010, even though Stack’s graded it higher, EF40, as a raw coin.  I think there is a moral to that story, which is that PCGS slabbed material tends to bring more money even when the grades are more conservative. 

Lot #3011, a 1788 Connecticut Miller 1-I in a F15 ANACS holder brought $6,900.  That coin was micro-porous, and would not have been graded that high at PCGS (for those who care about such things), but it still seemed pretty cheap compared to some of the less attractive examples that have sold in recent years.

Lot #3014, yet another Washington Roman Head Cent in a PF64 PCGS holder sold for $100,625 to an internet bidder, which is just a bit less than this same piece brought at Stack’s last summer.

Lot #3018, a not very original looking 1794 Talbot Allum & Lee Cent in a PCGS PF65 RB holdered brought over $10,000, which seemed like an awful lot of money to me.

Lot #3019, a hash lot of 19 pieces evidently group lotted because the catalogers deemed it nothing special, actually contained some choice Machin’s Mills pieces and sold for $3,737.50 to a well-known dealer.  I would guess one of the Machin’s alone might end up bringing that much on the aftermarket.

So what can we conclude about the first quarter?  Several things, I think;

  1. Even in the absence of a Ford-style mega-sale, or even a Keller-style giant collection like we saw last October at Heritage, there are plenty of interesting coins coming to market and seemingly ample demand to absorb them all.
     
  2. You just never know what will turn up, where.
     
  3. The market for rare die varieties across all series seems to be as strong as ever, much to my surprise.
     
  4. Common variety state coppers in F to AU with choice color and surfaces are very strong, while pieces with less than ideal surfaces and/or unattractive color seem to be selling for about what they brought 10 years ago (maybe 20).
     
  5. It does seem from my perspective that PCGS slabbed colonials are pretty much universally bringing more at auction than raw pieces or coins holdered by other services.
     
  6. The venues where raw colonials can be sold are rapidly dwindling.  With the merger of Bowers and Merena and Stack’s, I believe this trend is likely to accelerate in the future (the near future, such as in the second quarter, for example).  But we’ll all find out soon enough.

 

Coin Commentary Archive

September 20, 2017: Stream of Coin-sciousness

As our regular visitors have by now noticed, we’ve made the move from the sliiiightly cumbersome Coin Rarities Online to the streamlined CRO on the site...

August 31, 2017: August by the Numbers

If this is the last day of August it must be time to recap the month numerically starting right now: Just one:  Shows we attended this month – the ANA World’s Fair of Money in Denver...

June 1, 2017: Stream of Coin-sciousness

Ah yes, June, the official start of meteorilogical summer and an inevitable slow down in the coin business...

April 30, 2017: April by the Numbers

Great news everyone, it is time to recap the month of April numerically: 4 and a Half: Coin shows attended (one was a wrap-around that started in March)...

March 26, 2017: Stream of Coin-sciousness

Ah yes, April, a generally pleasant month for most people, but always, A-L-W-A-Y-S (for reasons we cannot explain) the most jam-packed month imaginable on the CRO numismatic calendar...

December 31, 2016: The Year In Review

As we rocket toward the end of another epic year here at CRO it is time once again for us to encapsulate, summarize and compress 12 frenetic months of numismatic activity into one profusely illustrated TYIR article...

November 11, 2016: Stream of Coin-sciousness

Inventory update: We’ve arrived at our intended steady-state website offering of about 200 coins (give or take), in the process beefing up a few areas where we’ve wanted to maintain a more robust assortment, namely Fugio Coppers and gold coins which circulated in early America...

July 31, 2016: July by the Numbers

With just a few days before we head out to the ANA in Anaheim, we’ve just enough time to numerically recap an especially hot month here at CRO starting right now: 26: New people who signed up for the Early Bird this month...

May 6, 2016: Stream of Coin-sciousness

You may notice some new social media logos and links popping up all over the site over the next few weeks/months as we leap boldly into the 21st century (or at least the part of it where people spend hours a day on Facebook, and post cool stuff on Pinterest)...

March 30, 2016: First Quarter Colonial Auction Recap

Editor's Note: A slightly modified version of the following article appeared in the Colonial Coin Collector's Club (C4) Newsletter, but since not all of our website visitors are C4 members, we thought we'd go ahead and post it here for your reading pleasure...

January 23, 2016: Stream of Coin-sciousness

While winter has descended upon us in earnest this month, it has not slowed down the activity level at CRO, with orders coming in at a pretty steady clip, and new coins arriving every day from literally all over the map...

December 31, 2015: The Year in Review

Celebratory trumpets blare forth, it is time to once again revel in another excellent CRO year which started waaaay back in early January in Orlando and finished here in the office 6 minutes ago when we received what is presumably the last order of 2015...

October 31, 2015: October by the Numbers

As we remove our thick, pancake Halloween makeup and neatly fold and put away our usual B. Max Mehl costume, it is time for another installment of CRO’s ‘By the Numbers’ in which we highlight a month numerically starting right now: 0: Coin shows attended in October...

March 30, 2015: CRO's View of the Kendall Foundation Collection

For the second time in just two months, we are delighted to find ourselves in the position of recapping another major colonial-centric auction containing another, ho hum, half dozen New England Shillings...

February 6, 2015: CRO's View of the Donald Partrick Collection, Part I

Forthwith we are pleased to present our usual CRO-style review of the Donald G. Partrick Collection, Part I, which was auctioned by Heritage at the FUN Show this year...

January 1, 2015: CRO's Numismatic New Year's Resolutions

After considerable thought, here's what we've come up with: Develop a better system to track global numismatic auctions this year so we don't miss anything good...

December 31, 2014: The Year in Review

As we stride confidently toward the end of another exciting year here at CRO it is time for us to pause briefly, reflect on the past year and then unleash some of the notable events here in our annual TYIR article...

November 16, 2014: CRO's View of the Eric Newman Collection, Part V

As a continuation of our May 17th Commentary on the Eric Newman colonial auction Part IV, we are pleased to add our thoughts on the recently concluded colonial auction Part V just held in New York...

August 31st, 2014: August by the Numbers

Right before the exciting start of another school year here in New England, it is, yes, time for another installment of CRO’s ‘August by the Numbers’ in which we highlight the month numerically starting right now: Only one: Shows attended this month, though of course it was the Big Kahuna, the Grand Daddy of Them All, the World’s Fair of Money held in, once again, Rosemont, IL...

May 17, 2014: CRO's View of the Eric Newman Collection, Part IV

We recently had the distinct pleasure of attending the sale of the Eric Newman Collection, Part IV (the colonials!), in New York...

April 16, 2014: The Numismatic Fall from Grace

Numismatic Fall from Grace: n(y)o͞oməzˈmatik fôl frəm grās.  noun phrase...

December 30, 2013: The Year in Review

With mere hours to go before the start of 2014, it is once again time to pause, take a deep, cleansing breath and reflect on the always interesting, occasionally exceptional, sometimes record setting, unfortunately unappetizing, deeply heartening and often entertaining things that happened to us in 2013...

November 18, 2013: CRO's View of the Eric Newman Collection, Part II

As our loyal readers have almost certainly heard, seen and experienced by now, last week a significant numismatic event took place in New York in the form of installment 2 of the Eric P...

October 21, 2013: Stream of Coin-sciousness

In the midst of what has to be the most pleasant New England fall weather I’ve ever experienced (unlike some previous years when we were already shoveling snow by this date), business has continued nicely, with steady sales and more than our fair share of interesting NEWPs...

July 21, 2013: Stream of Coin-sciousness

After an action packed early summer which has taken us from Long Beach to Mexico to Kentucky to Edinburgh, Scotland, we are pleased to be back just in time to write this looong overdue installment of the CC...

March 31, 2013: CRO's 'March by the Numbers'

With a mini-lull between tax time and our next show, we have taken the opportunity to crank out another exciting edition of CRO's 'By the Numbers' in which we highlight a month numerically starting right now: Just one: Shows attended this month, though it was that real big one in Baltimore...

January 23, 2013: Stack's-Bowers Americana Colonial Auction Recap

Aaah yes, when the numismatic calendar turns to late January, it can only mean one thing: It’s time for another fantastic Stack’s-Bowers Americana auction held, as always, on fabulous 57th Street in Manhattan...

December 28, 2012: The Year in Review

Let’s see, with 2012 winding down and another fantastic FUN show just about to begin it must be time for another edition of The Year in Review – you know, the all-encompassing piece where we highlight the most memorable (though not necessarily good) things that happened to us in the past year...

November 3, 2012: Stream of Coin-sciousness

Time to take a deep, relaxing breath here at CRO World Headquarters as we head into what will be, without any doubt whatsoever, the busiest November in our super-illustrious history...

September 15, 2012: Stream of Coin-sciousness

Well, it’s been about 6 weeks since the birth of the “new” CRO, which I hope most observers / collectors / dealers and visitors to the website have concluded looks very much like the “old” CRO...

July 30, 2012: Ch-ch-ch-changes

Note that today’s Coin Commentary is presented in CRO’s familiar Point-Counterpoint format with JA’s comments in blue and DW’s in red...

May 19, 2012: Stream of Coin-sciousness

Today was an exciting day at CRO (at least by coin-geek standards), as Dave received our grades back on a recent submission and informed me that they included an unc...

April 26, 2012: The Salmon Classification System for Massachusetts Silver Coins

We are pleased to present this discussion and explanation of the new Salmon classification system for Massachusetts Silver Coins written by Dr...

March 1, 2012: Rosen Numismatic Advisory Crystal Ball Survey, Part 2

As promised, and like clockwork, we are herewith pleased to present the 35th Annual Rosen Numismatic Advisory Crystal Ball Survey, Part 2 for your reading pleasure...

February 1, 2012: Rosen Numismatic Advisory Crystal Ball Survey, Part I

We are herewith pleased to present the 35th Annual Rosen Numismatic Advisory Crystal Ball Survey, Part I, a forward-looking questionnaire sent to a group of numismatic industry heavyweights including John Albanese, founder of Collector's Acceptance Corporation (CAC), William Paul of American Heritage Minting, Laura Sperber of Legend Numismatics, Scott Travers of Scott Travers Numismatics, Doug Winter of Doug Winter Numismatics and our own Dave Wnuck...

December 29, 2011: The Year in Review

If this is the end of December, it must once again be time for an epic installment of TYIR (even though it feels like we just finished writing the 2010 version)...

December 12, 2011: Stream of Coin-sciousness

While the weather here in New England has been surprisingly mild of late, business has been anything but...

September 23, 2011: Stream of Coin-sciousness

Now that we have a few week lull between shows in Pennsylvania, it seems an excellent time to address the following question:  Why do we have two shows in a row in Pennsylvania?  To which the answer is of course:  We have no idea...

August 7, 2011: What is that Red and White Square on Your Home Page?

E. M. of Farmington, MI emailed recently to ask what that red and white square symbol on our home page means...

May 23, 2011: Stream of Coin-sciousness

Ah yes, there is nothing like traveling all over this great land to attend coin shows. But as much as we really enjoy them, there are occasional instances (such as during a 6 hour flight to Portland next to a screaming child) that we wish we could hang out at home more often...

March 31, 2011: First Quarter Colonial Auction Recap

The following article by our own John Agre appeared in the Colonial Coin Collector's Club (C4) Newsletter, but since not all of our website visitors are C4 members, we thought we'd go ahead and post it here for your reading pleasure (though with the addition of a bunch of no-holds-barred editorial comments that we reserved for this site): It’s been a pretty interesting first three months of the year in the world of colonial coin auctions, with significant offerings from Stack’s and Heritage, an interesting piece or two at Bowers and Merena, and an assortment of coins on Ebay ranging from the fairly typical (i...

March 2, 2011: In Memory of My Friend Steve Tanenbaum

I am in shock. My longtime friend, token and medal dealer extraordinaire Steve Tanenbaum, is no longer with us...

January 21, 2011: Stream of Coin-sciousness

Sales continue to be robust around here, which is delightful, except for the part about battling yet another impressive (or impressively disgusting) New England snow storm in order to ship out the latest round of boxes...

December 27, 2010: The Year in Review

And this one really flew by, as it seems like just yesterday we were at the FUN Show back in January of this year laughing at the valet parking attendant dressed like Nanook of the North in 30 degree weather...

November 12, 2010: CRO Goes Hollywood, Part Deux!

That’s right – it is time once again for a recap of my experience as an “Expert Appraiser” (please – hold your applause) on Connecticut Public Television’s Connecticut Treasure Appraisal Fair! Which this year was conveniently scheduled on the Sunday right after the Whitman Show in Baltimore, affording me the excellent opportunity to race home completely exhausted after a busy week, wake up very early the next day, get all gussied up for a possible TV appearance and then zoom to the Mohegan Sun Casino Arena for the scheduled 7 AM start...

August 31, 2010: CRO's 'August by the Numbers'

Good news everyone - it’s time once again for our annual 'August by the Numbers' commentary in which we summarize our business in the 8th month numerically...

June 11, 2010: The Find

Another Original Work of Numismatic Non-Fiction by Dave Wnuck So I’m sitting in the CRO offices one day a couple of weeks ago when the phone rings...

March 15, 2010: Corrections to the Whitman Encyclopedia

As our readers may remember, it was almost exactly one year ago when we wrote a Coin Commentary containing a review of Whitman's then-new Encyclopedia of Colonial and Early American Coins...

December 31, 2009: The Year in Review

In the most vivid illustration yet that ‘Time Flies’, we have now reached the end of 2009, our 4th full year together as CRO and, by any objective (or subjective) measure, the best one yet...

November 25, 2009: So you want to be a cataloger, eh?

Well, so did we, which may explain why team CRO is listed in this year’s C4 (Colonial Coin Collectors Club) catalog under the “Cataloging by ...

November 9, 2009: CRO Goes Hollywood!

Well, sort of. I was selected once again to be the official Coin & Currency appraiser for CPTV's Connecticut Treasure Hunt Appraisal Fair, an annual event held this year on November 8th...

September 27th, 2009: We Have a Winner(s)!

We say 'winner(s)' because there are two.  In the first annual CRO "What Does the 'L' Counterstamp Stand for on the 1825 Quarter?" contest, that is...

August 31, 2009: CRO's 'August by the Numbers'

Just 1:  Coin shows we attended. 44:  CRO checks written there. 4 Big Boxes:  Quantity of NEWPs sent out for photography from the show...

July 11, 2009: The Mentor-ist

More Numismatic Non-Fiction By Dave Wnuck Have you ever heard someone described as a ‘natural’ in numismatics?  I have – usually referring to a person who seems to have an intuitive gift for grading, or for coming up with great coins, or for finding ready buyers, etc...

May 21, 2009: Book Review, Part II

In our last Coin Commentary (gee, time sure does fly around here) we reprinted a review of the new Whitman Encyclopedia of Colonial and Early American Coins by Wayne Homren...

March 25, 2009: Book Review

Recently Wayne Homren, Editor of the fantastic and highly recommended E-sylum (which, in their own words, is described as "a weekly electronic newsletter published by the Numismatic Bibliomania Society for numismatic bibliophiles, researchers, and just plain numismatists around the world"), wrote a review of the new Whitman Encyclopedia of Colonial and Early American Coins...

March 5, 2009: So you're going to a coin show, eh?

Some time ago a client of ours recommended that we write a Coin Commentary for collectors attending a first show...

February 18, 2009: Notable Numismatic Quotables, Part I

Over the years we've heard and read a number of interesting and thought provoking numismatic quotes from a variety of sources (actually, we've come up with a few on our own, too)...

December 27, 2008: The Year in Review

It's time once again for Dave and me to reflect back on another year of traveling to coin shows and auctions, meeting a lot of nice people, buying and selling cool coins, visiting new cities, using just under 2 miles of packing tape, waiting for hours at various airport baggage carousels, filling out grading forms, etc...

Thanksgiving, 2008: Thank you

Thank you. Thank you to our loyal customers who make it possible for Dave and me to travel around the country going to coin shows and auctions instead of commuting to work at some company that makes widgets and serves as the inspiration for the comic strip 'Dilbert'...

October 1, 2008: Coin Collecting in an Uncertain World

As usual, we're going to tell it like it is in our Coin Commentary. You see, we actually have a number of incredibly clever new topics lined up and ready to go for this section of the site (based on lots of good suggestions by many of our regular visitors), but frankly it seemed odd to post some of them at this point...

July 23, 2008: On CAC

As some of you have already noticed, a number of coins in our current inventory are now identified as having CAC stickers...

July 14, 2008: What are Your Choices for the 100 Greatest US Coins?

That was the question posed to me recently by the good folks at Whitman Publishing. It seems they are hard at work on the shiny new 3rd Edition of their extremely popular coffee table book, The 100 Greatest US Coins, and so they have asked me and a group of other (and I quote) "dealers, collectors, researchers, historians and others connected to the field" to vote on the list...

May 19, 2008: My Love Affair with a Fat, Old Woman

An Original Work of Numismatic Non-Fiction by Dave Wnuck. Shhhhh. Don't tell my wife, but I'm in love with another woman...

March 31, 2008: An Ode to . . . John Agre(?) by Dave Wnuck

This Coin Commentary may sound nakedly self-promotional, but I'd like to tell the folks out there a little about my business partner and the half owner of Coin Rarities Online, John Agre...

February 9, 2008: Colonial Coin Collecting Q & A, Part 2

Waaaaaay back in August of 2006 we wrote part 1 of this Q & A with every intention of adding Part 2 eventually...

December 26, 2007: The Year in Review

As another exciting numismatic year winds to a close, it is appropriate that we look back and reflect on the new friends we made, the coins we bought and sold, the fun we had, the memorable meals we enjoyed, the wonderful grades we received, the bad bus rides we took and the myriad other events which, in total, conspired to make this the finest and most enjoyable year ever in the history of CRO, ever...

November 15, 2007: How Come the Coins Went so Cheap?

I got an email from a customer the other day who had been watching the Stack's 'Amherst & Waccubuc' catalog colonial session online and seeing (with a handful of notable exceptions) very low prices or coins not meeting reserve...

November 2, 2007: Ten Coins we Could Buy and Sell Ten Times

This idea for a Coin Commentary was submitted by one of our customers, and I liked the idea so much that I just started flailing away on the keyboard immediately...

September 10, 2007: So How's the Coin Market? (Parts 1 & 2)

That's a question dealers (including us) hear all of the time from customers. And while responses to this question may vary wildly depending on who you ask, this is our Coin Commentary and here you will get the 'CRO View' (which happens to be pretty well researched)...

July 31, 2007: How Can You Avoid Buying Doctored Coins?

We recently received an email from a collector who was dismayed by the number of doctored, conserved and enhanced coins in TPG holders in the marketplace...

July 4, 2007: Life is Too Short to Buy Ugly Coins

At the recent Baltimore show, I spent a fair amount of time walking the floor perusing the gazillion dealer tables looking for nice coins to buy...

May 27, 2007: The Right Stuff

Is what I saw during a recent visit to view a customer's collection. He graciously invited me to travel to meet him and view his coins, and, of course, I enthusiastically accepted...

April 14, 2007: What should you do with a sub-par coin?

Let's say you have a coin in your collection that really isn't up to snuff. And I don't mean one that is too low grade, or not expensive enough...

March 16, 2007: Why are we talking about trains?

That's an excellent question - thank you for asking. Actually, the answer is quite simple. One of the most informative and important articles I've ever read about coin collecting actually wasn't about coins at all...

Michael Kent Ringo: 05/28/54 - 01/28/07

We lost a good friend and numismatic colleague this week with the passing of Mike Ringo. Most coin collectors and dealers may have never heard of Mike...

January 18, 2007: Should Coins be Purchased as an Investment?

You're in for a treat today, especially since Dave and I totally disagree on this topic. Which means this will be our first Point-Counterpoint Coin Commentary, almost certain to be filled with polite disagreement possibly culminating in pure, unbridled acrimony with computer YELLING in all caps...

December 1, 2006: How NOT to Buy Coins at Auction

We felt compelled to write this week’s Coin Commentary as a sort of numismatic public service announcement after watching all kinds of people buy all kinds of coins at auction over the last couple of decades...

October 10, 2006: Dave Speaks About the Market

Interesting times in the coin market. After an almost unprecedented multi-year run-up in demand, prices and euphoria, we are seeing some changes...

August 30, 2006: Colonial Coin Collecting Q & A, Part 1

An increasing portion of our business is in colonial coins, and so we thought it was about time for us to speak up...

July 18, 2006: One Vote for the 'Box-of-20' Concept

We have been around coins for a long, long time, and we've seen people collect coins of all different kinds in all different ways, from type sets to die varieties to date and mint runs in all series to the odd...

June 9, 2006: Once sold, what item(s) in your inventory will be hardest to replace?

Someone asked us this on the phone today and we thought it was an interesting, thought provoking question...

May 26, 2006: So how much of a premium above sheet levels would you pay for a choice original coin?

Lots of people say they want them. That they value originality. That they hate to see original coins stripped and dipped and ruined...

May 6, 2006: What makes a good client?

Someone asked us this at a recent show and, as is our want, we like to answer particularly interesting or provacative questions right here on the ol' website...

April 16, 2006: Top 10 things we would change about coin slabbing

In no particular order: All slabbed coins would be photographed by the services and would thus be traceable, and it would therefore be impossible to crack out and resubmit a coin and receive a higher grade than the one originally conferred...

April 4, 2006: Do you guys BUY coins for these prices?????

A gentleman came to our table at the Baltimore show a couple of weeks ago, looked in the case for a while, admired a couple of coins, asked a few prices and then with a slightly pained and sarcastic scowl asked me what was apparently intended to be a stinging question: Do you guys buy coins for these prices? The implication of this question was, of course, that our prices are high...

March 19, 2006: Will the last original coin to leave please turn out the lights?

Heres an experiment for you: Go to view lots at a typical major auction. Look through every box of every series and jot down how many original, uncorrupted coins you find...

March 5, 2006: Thoughts on Coin Grading, Part 1

We thought we'd tackle a not-controversial, simple and easy topic like 'coin grading' this week. We’ll start with how we, as dealers, grade and assess a coin: Whether it is in an auction, in another dealer’s case, raw or slabbed, we evaluate a coin by studying it carefully and determining, regardless of the level of wear in evidence, whether we like it or not...

January 15, 2006: Why should I buy from a dealer?

In our experience, this question is typically followed by a statement that goes something like this: "I can just buy from auctions myself, so I really don't need to pay a dealer...

December 26, 2005: The Big Picture

As we’ve had a few days to relax, enjoy the holidays and spend some time with our families, we’ve had a little time to step back and reflect on the year...

 


All Content is Copyright © 2006-2017 Coin Rarities Online, LLC. All rights reserved.
Top Seller Website Software is Copyright © 2004, 2005, 2006 Identry, LLC. All rights reserved.