See us at the Early American Coppers Convention in Indianapolis, IN, May 16-18

Updated: May 18th 9:10AM ET
(800) Coins-99:  7AM - 11PM ET EVERY DAY


Retail Facilities

CRO maintains no retail facilities. All coins are stored in bank vaults.

Terms & Conditions of Sale

Placing an Order
We accept orders by phone or email, anytime, and we fill them in the sequence in which they are received. We ask our customers to please note, though, that all items on our list are one of a kind in our inventory, and once they are ordered by one customer they cannot be ordered by another. As such, and in fairness to all, we kindly request that you order an item only if you are reasonably serious about it, understand and accept our price, and have sufficient funds to pay for it.

Guarantee of Authenticity
Coin Rarities Online (referred to as CRO from here on) unconditionally guarantees that all uncertified coins that we offer are genuine (or ‘as described’, if the item is a collectable contemporary counterfeit). For coins certified by independent coin grading services, including PCGS, NGC, CACG and ANACS, their guarantees of authenticity will apply.

Our retail prices are set based on what we believe are appropriate levels given the rarity and quality of the items offered and our cost to replace them. We do reserve the right, though, to change our posted prices at any time due to market fluctuations or simply to correct typographical errors and misstatements. It does happen occasionally.

Shipping, Handling and Insurance
All CRO prices are inclusive of shipping and insurance for orders within the United States unless otherwise specified (such as in the case of an over-sized item like an enormous coin cabinet, for example).

Methods of Payment
We accept payment for purchases from CRO in cash, by bank check, postal money order, credit card, PayPal or wire transfer. We will take personal checks as well, but we will have to wait for them to clear before shipping merchandise unless you can provide suitable references or we have a history of successful transactions with you.

Retail sales invoices of $1,000 and under delivered in Massachusetts to state residents are subject to 6.25% tax.  Sales to customers in states which do NOT have numismatic or bullion exemptions are subject to tax at the rates specified by each state.

We will consider any serious proposal you wish to make to trade your numismatic item(s) for coins in our inventory, provided that you inform us of your desire to trade before placing an order.

Title to Merchandise
CRO retains title to all items until we receive payment in full for them.

Return Policy
Any item purchased from CRO may be returned for a full refund for any reason, provided that it has not been altered from the condition in which you received it. For the avoidance of any confusion, if you buy a certified coin from us and then remove it from the slab, it is no longer returnable. To make a return, you must notify us of your intent within 5 days of receiving the item from us. All returns must then be mailed back to us, per our specified shipping method within 7 days of receipt. Any exceptions to this policy must be approved by CRO, in advance, in writing. Note that we also reserve the right to refuse orders from customers who have returned an unreasonably high percentage of items in the past.

Layaway Plans and Terms
We offer a layaway service on purchases of $2,000 or more, provided that you inform us of your intent to pay over time when placing your order. Generally we would want to receive 1/3 of the purchase price at the time of your order, the second 1/3 in 30 days and the last 1/3 in 60 days, though we will consider alternative arrangements and terms on a case-by-case basis. On any layaway, CRO will maintain possession of the coin until it is paid in full. Note that if you change your mind on any layaway item and wish to return it either before or after we receive the final payment, we will have to charge you a restocking fee of 10% of the original purchase price.

Prompt Payment
When you make a purchase from CRO, you are personally guaranteeing that you will make prompt payment in full (including applicable taxes, if any) per agreed terms. If you make a purchase acting as an agent on behalf of another individual or corporation (in any capacity), the person signing for receipt of the goods personally guarantees prompt payment and agrees to be held personally liable for the consequences of the purchase.

Penalties for Late Payment
Although we sincerely do not wish to do so, CRO reserves the right to impose a late fee, or periodic charge, if a purchaser fails to remit full and immediate payment per agreed terms. The rate shall be calculated as 1.5% per month (18% per annum) of the unpaid balance due to CRO. Additionally, purchasers agree to pay CRO’s reasonable attorneys’ fees and costs required to collect on past due accounts. Note that we will refuse orders from any customers with sufficiently shaky payment history.

Purchasers Claiming Tax Exempt Status
Purchasers claiming exemption from any taxes due on the purchase of goods must submit resale or other exemption certificates to CRO.

Filing Requirements for Cash Transactions
Note that IRS regulations state that IRS form 8300 must be filed for cash transactions exceeding $10,000 within one calendar year.

Legal Disputes
Though rare, disputes or disagreements may sometimes arise in the normal course of any business. It is our strong preference to try to address any such issues personally and directly to find amicable resolution, and we commit to do so. But if all else fails, we reserve the right to pursue matters legally if necessary to protect our rights. In such case, any legal disputes with CRO will be adjudicated in Middlesex County, Massachusetts.

Coin Market Risk Factors

  1. The coin market is subject to substantial fluctuations including significant and rapid increases and decreases in value from time to time.
  2. The coin market is largely unregulated.
  3. Certification by a grading or verifying service does not guarantee protection against the normal risks associated with the coin market.
  4. The degree of liquidity of a particular item will vary according to general market conditions, and there may be no active market at all for some items at certain points in time.